We’re Not Just Insurance Anymore

February 6, 2018

Everyone knows the Mitchell Insurance Agency was founded in 1961, is family owned and operated, and provides insurance for your business and personal needs. What you probably don’t know is we’re not just insurance anymore. In fact, we’re A LOT more than insurance. As shown below, our goal is to make your life easier & more efficient by providing all your service needs in one convenient location. Most importantly, when you need us most, we will be right by your side. Call…… Read More >

2017 NJ Herald Reader’s Choice Award for Best Insurance Agency!

May 31, 2017

2017 Gold Ribbon Color

We are excited to announce that the Mitchell Insurance Agency received the GOLD medal for “Best Insurance Agency” in the 2017 NJ Herald Readers Choice Awards. These awards honor the best locally owned and operated businesses in Sussex County & the surrounding areas. We would like to thank everyone for your continued support in voting us the best agency TWO years in a row, we truly appreciate it. This award means a lot, because we take pride in our work…… Read More >

Keith Mitchell Turns 60!

November 11, 2016


Keith Mitchell celebrated his 60th birthday today (11/11). All the employees at the Mitchell Insurance Agency surprised him with a beautiful framed picture of Newton Country Club & a picture of him when he was 18 years old superimposed on his cake. Also, his entire staff wore t-shirts with a cartoon likeness of Keith as bodybuilders holding a balloon with “60” written on it. Good times were had by all & Keith took it all in stride. Happy Birthday… Read More >