973.383.5800

  • The Mitchell Insurance Agency treats you like family. They have a vast knowledge of personal and business products that are explained in a way that is easy to understand. The staff is prompt and courteous. I value that it is a locally owned business. Keith and Heather are always a phone call away!

    - ,

  • Thank you for treating me like a human and not a number! The personalized service was refreshing and I dealt with the same person who was familiar with my account and went the extra mile to resolve my issue. The claim support is excellent!

    - ,

  • I trust the Mitchell family. They are true professionals who take the time to review our policies and get us the best possible quotes for our specific needs. They provided a quick response and competitive pricing. I appreciate the honesty and trustworthiness of this “hometown” business!

    - ,

  • Through email or mailings, the Mitchell Insurance Agency keeps you informed. They take care me as if I was a member of their family and take a personal interest in my company. Prompt, knowledgeable and courteous, the Mitchell Insurance Agency goes the extra mile!

    - ,

  • The Mitchell Insurance Agency provides exceptional personalized service in a relaxed environment. They are a home-town business and only a few blocks away; yet it feels very professional. I get the sense that the Mitchell Insurance Agency is a well-run business.

    - ,

  • We use the Mitchell Insurance Agency to fulfill all of our corporate and health care insurance needs. I was able to deal with a single agent, and they shopped to get us the best possible insurance package.

    - ,

  • They offer competitive prices and helped us with our insurance needs. Keith listened and took the time to understand my specific needs.

    - ,

  • We love dealing with the Mitchell Insurance Agency staff! They are able to deliver very competitive rates and sound advice. They go above and beyond for their clients.

    - ,

  • Thank you for providing timely and important seminars regarding insurance needs. I can’t praise this locally owned, family ran business enough!

    - ,

  • The Mitchell Insurance Agency goes the extra mile to help their clients. They are fast and reliable with personal knowledge about me and my business. The quality of the staff and service is outstanding!

    - ,

  • Best insurance agency around! Have been with them happily for over 8 years!!!

    - ,

  • The Mitchell Insurance Agency is amazing the staff is always so helpful with all of our needs for our business insurance as well as our personal healthcare. We have been happy clients for several years now and would not think of going anywhere else.

    - ,

  • I been working with Jessica Martinez for over ten years . Anytime you need something she gets me to the right person. The personal touch that she gives my company is the reason why the Mitchell Insurance Agency is great to work with.

    - ,

  • The Mitchell Agency handles all my polices. Tracy Colburn takes care of our business needs, always quick to respond to any questions or concerns that come up. I highly recommend this agency.

    - ,

  • Completely knowledgeable staff. They were able to answer all my questions and are very professional. Highly recommend!

    - ,

  • Family operated, with professional, courteous and knowledgeable staff; always engaged with our needs and ready to help even if it means obtaining outside resources. Excellent agency and in our own community.

    - ,

  • Greg Orlando has been exceptional to deal with, Extremely knowledgeable, caring and professional. Highly recommend.

    - ,

  • Great customer service with knowledgeable staff. I rely on the Mitchell Agency for all of my business insurance coverage.

    - ,

  • I usually have gone with bigger name insurance companies until I found the Mitchell Agency! Janiel Fusco helped save me money while adding better options to my coverage! I will refer her everyone I know. Who doesn't want to save money?!

    - ,

  • The Mitchell Agency is the BEST!! Michael Montague is great to work with.... very professional and goes the extra mile to help. Excellent customer service....Thanks Mitchell Agency!

    - ,

  • Michael Montague is an excellent and efficient worker at the Mitchell Insurance Agency. He is always willing to go above and beyond for us at the Samaritan Inn, Inc. & It is greatly appreciated.

    - ,

  • Thank You Mitchell Insurance Agency for making life a little easier. Lauren Trovillion helps me with whatever I need within the hour. It's a pleasure doing business with the Mitchell Agency.

    - ,

  • Jessica Martinez is a god-send! Impeccable service, great availability and a wonderful attitude to work with! Keep it up.

    - ,

  • The Mitchell Agency is great agency to do business with. It is very responsive too my business insurance needs. Ashley Ollo goes above and beyond to make things happen in a timely mater.

    - ,

  • The Mitchell Agency and all the staff go above and beyond. All of us at McGuire Chevrolet Cadillac appreciate all they do for us and would recommend them to anyone.

    - ,

  • What started out as a tough winter with a burst pipe and 3 floors of damage ... has turned around in a quick 6 weeks and we are starting to get back to normal! A huge thank you to the Mitchell Agency ... Serve-pro Cleaning Crew and Tom Madsen for an amazing repair and rebuild! We would have been lost without you!!

    - ,

The Mitchell Insurance Agency has been providing exceptional service with a professional approach for your business and personal needs since 1961.

More
While you focus on your future, we help protect it.